Skip to content
    Log in

      Handmade cookie cutters, keychains, fidgets and home decor – perfect for creative baking and personalized gifts.

        Log in Cart

        Item added to your cart

        View cart

        Shop our Customizable Cookie Cutters

        • Text reading 'Animal Cookie Cutters' in rounded white letters with a light blue outline on a pale gray background.

          🐾 Animal Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🐾 Animal Cookie Cutters

        • 🍼 Baby Shower Cutters

          🍼 Baby Shower Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🍼 Baby Shower Cutters

        • 🎂 Birthday Cookie Cutters

          🎂 Birthday Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🎂 Birthday Cookie Cutters

        • 🎄 Christmas Cookie Cutters

          🎄 Christmas Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🎄 Christmas Cookie Cutters

        • 🐣 Easter Cookie Cutters

          🐣 Easter Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🐣 Easter Cookie Cutters

        • 🍂 Fall Cookie Cutters

          🍂 Fall Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🍂 Fall Cookie Cutters

        • 🧚 Fantasy Cookie Cutters

          🧚 Fantasy Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🧚 Fantasy Cookie Cutters

        • 🐮 Farm Animal Cutters

          🐮 Farm Animal Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🐮 Farm Animal Cutters

        • 😂 Funny Cookie Cutters

          😂 Funny Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          😂 Funny Cookie Cutters

        • 🎃 Halloween Cookie Cutters

          🎃 Halloween Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🎃 Halloween Cookie Cutters

        • ⚓ Nautical Cookie Cutters

          ⚓ Nautical Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          ⚓ Nautical Cookie Cutters

        • ✝️ Religious Cookie Cutters

          ✝️ Religious Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          ✝️ Religious Cookie Cutters

        • 🔷 Geometric Cookie Cutters

          🔷 Geometric Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🔷 Geometric Cookie Cutters

        • 🌸 Spring Cookie Cutters

          🌸 Spring Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          🌸 Spring Cookie Cutters

        • ☘️ St. Patrick's Day Cutters

          ☘️ St. Patrick's Day Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          ☘️ St. Patrick's Day Cutters

        • ❤️ Valentine’s Day Cutters

          ❤️ Valentine’s Day Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          ❤️ Valentine’s Day Cutters

        • 💍 Wedding Cookie Cutters

          💍 Wedding Cookie Cutters

          1"–10" Sizes • 30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping...

          💍 Wedding Cookie Cutters

        1 / of 17

        Bulk Keychains for Events & Party Favors

        • 🐾 Animal Keychains

          🐾 Animal Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          🐾 Animal Keychains

        • 👶 Baby Shower Keychains

          👶 Baby Shower Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          👶 Baby Shower Keychains

        • 🎉 Party Favor Keychains

          🎉 Party Favor Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          🎉 Party Favor Keychains

        • 🏫 Class Prize Keychains

          🏫 Class Prize Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          🏫 Class Prize Keychains

        • 🐇 Easter Keychains

          🐇 Easter Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          🐇 Easter Keychains

        • 🎃 Halloween Keychains

          🎃 Halloween Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          🎃 Halloween Keychains

        • ⚓ Nautical Keychains

          ⚓ Nautical Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          ⚓ Nautical Keychains

        • 👷 Occupational Keychains

          👷 Occupational Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          👷 Occupational Keychains

        • ✝️ Religious Keychains

          ✝️ Religious Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          ✝️ Religious Keychains

        • ❤️ Valentine’s Day Keychains

          ❤️ Valentine’s Day Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          ❤️ Valentine’s Day Keychains

        • 💍 Wedding Favor Keychains

          💍 Wedding Favor Keychains

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          💍 Wedding Favor Keychains

        1 / of 11

        Fidget & Pretend Play Toys Collections

        • 🌀 Fidget, Spinners & Articulated Toys

          🌀 Fidget, Spinners & Articulated Toys

          Bulk Pricing • As Low as $0.80 Each • Made in USA...

          🌀 Fidget, Spinners & Articulated Toys

        • 🎭 Pretend Play Toys

          🎭 Pretend Play Toys

          Encourage imagination and creativity with our pretend play toys, designed for hands-on...

          🎭 Pretend Play Toys

        Home Accessories & Gift Cards

        • 🏡 Home Accessories

          🏡 Home Accessories

          30 Colors • Made in USA • Free Shipping $20+ Add something...

          🏡 Home Accessories

        • Gift Cards

          Gift Cards

          Give them the freedom to choose exactly what they want with a...

          Gift Cards

        Check out our reviews!

        4.98 ★ (229)
        Verified
        The Cookie Craftor logo design featuring a clean, modern style that represents eco-friendly keychains, fidgets, and cookie cutters.

        Who is TheCookieCraftor?

        At The Cookie Craftor, we’re a small, family-owned business dedicated to creating affordable, eco-friendly, and sustainable small gifts for every occasion—including cookie cutters, keychains, fidgets, and more. Every order ships in eco-friendly packaging, from recyclable poly mailers to sustainable packing materials—because we care about what happens after it leaves our hands.

        Additionally, we are committed to providing an accessible shopping experience. If you have any issues, please contact us at info@thecookiecraftor.com or click the Chat icon in the lower right corner and we will assist you in any way possible.




        Subscribe to our Monthly Newsletter (sent on the 1st of every month) to see our new products and receive exclusive deals!

        Payment methods
        • American Express
        • Apple Pay
        • Diners Club
        • Discover
        • Google Pay
        • Mastercard
        • PayPal
        • Shop Pay
        • Visa
        © 2026, The Cookie Craftor
        • Privacy policy
        • Contact information
        • Refund policy
        • Terms of service
        • Shipping policy
        • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
        • Opens in a new window.